Audit Failure

Audit Failure

Lost Cask 7 Year Single Malt

Sandalwood Incense & Treacle

Pedro Ximénez Distillery-smoked Washington Peat

PPM: 13

We laid this cask down seven years ago and promptly forgot about it in the darkest corner of the maturation room. While its friends were out getting bottled, this solitary butt was quietly turning into something weird, wonderful, and totally unexpected. Dive into a velvety hug of distant campfire smoke, sticky marmalade, and dark chocolate-roasted almonds, ending with an unapologetic sherry kick. Turns out, a little ghosting does a whisky good.

This perfect after-dinner dram has distant campfire, sandalwood incense, Sherry, dried fruits, and treacle toffee on the nose. The palate is rich and velvety, with lovely bonfire notes, sultanas, prunes, figs, and delicate sun-dried PX grape notes. These develop into cocoa powder, dark chocolate-roasted almonds, marmalade, warming wood spices, including cloves and nutmeg, and dark molasses. The finish is dry, with lingering Sherry wine, light smoke, and oak spices.

No colour added. Non-chill filtered.

Distilled, matured and bottled in Victoria, British Columbia, Canada.

100% Canadian owned & operated.

Lightly peated at 13 ppm, with BC barley smoked at the distillery over Washington State peat and matured in a single sherry butt. Curious what ppm means? Our Peated Whisky Guide explains it and where to start.


600 Bottles Only
Bottle Size: 750 mL
ABV
Regular price $200.00 CAD
Regular price Sale price $200.00 CAD
Sale Sold out
Shipping calculated at checkout.
Quantity

Our core range taste profile

Our award-winning single malt whiskies combine the finest Canadian barley together with the traditional craft of Scotland's finest whisky makers, distilled to perfection in our hand-hammered Forsyth's copper pot stills.

  • 5 stars: 15 (83%)
  • 4 stars: 2 (11%)
  • 3 stars: 1 (6%)
  • 2 stars: 0 (0%)
  • 1 star: 0 (0%)
C
Catherine Semple

My wife bought Audit Failure as a celebratory gift. It is incredibly smooth and goes down very easily.

M
Mike Geller

Its really well balanced and spicy!

G
Gil Hopkins

Fantastic 👍

A
Anonymous

smooth tasty great finish

A
Anonymous

Truly Excellent,
Please forget about another some time soon

M
Mark E Harcourt

Complex, full flavoured, decadent. Definitely a celebratory drink.

R
Rickie Melvin Chaykowski

Audit Failure is quite a good whiskey, however, not worth the price. One can buy a much better scotch from Scotland for $200.

c
cecilia

Perfect blend of smoothness, flavour and peatiness. Superb.

D
Darcy McClimon

I sent this with Dave on a 'guys weekend' fishing trip and they all loved it!!

A
Anonymous

Excellent!

G
Grant Usher

It was great on the pallet with nice mouth feel. I had a bit of an issue with the nose in that I was picking up an anise seed note, maybe some heads or tails?? The ABV was spot on! I also really enjoyed the Peat Project bottle I had shipped in the same order! Soooo good and that peat note of campfire hit all the right spots!

A
Anonymous

Beautifully complex and flavourful! If this is failure, please continue failing!

R
Richard Jack

One word. Delicious

V
Val Kowalewich

Beautiful. Elegant. Mystical. A little water or ice opens this failure right up. Wonderful fall notes and spice. Deep warmth - lots going on in this one.

R
Ross Barlow

Outstanding! One of the best I’ve ever had the pleasure to sample. It’s a real treasure! I wish I could give it more stars.

A
Alistair Jackson

Audit Failure is very, very good indeed. Complex and interesting, it's a worthy first stepping stone for those who are just beginning to explore peated malts. Yet it also pleases the palate of those who love a full bodied sherry cask. Being one of the older Macaloney's expressions, Audit Failure also offers a foretaste of things to come ... great things I believe. I have been engaged with Macaloney's since its beginning and I'm excited to continue sipping as the barrels age and the distillery matures.

E
Eric Day

Awesome. Smooth rich and very enjoyable. Yes there is a peaty flavour but its not harsh like Lagavulin or other super peaty distillations.

M
Mike

tastes great

Friends of Macaloney's

Pete the marmot

MERROIR

$150/year

For our salty friends who want more than a taste.


  • Includes a bottle of Truth Serum
  • Shipping on us all year, no minimum
  • 10% off every bottle, all year
  • 48 hour early access on every release
  • A distillery tour each year, bring a guest
  • Quarterly Flavour Files: tasting notes, ingredient deep dives and cask profiles
  • Priority booking for events
  • A welcome tee in your choice of design and size
  • Everything in Terroir

ARBOIR

$500/year

Our insider membership for characters who want to season with us.

Limited Membership


  • Includes a bottle of Audit Failure
  • First access to every release, 72 hours before Merroir
  • Palate matched picks from Arboir only single casks, two or three a year
  • Welcome kit: four Glencairns, branded merch and a numbered member certificate
  • Three complimentary club events a year
  • A private Cask Library evening each year with Margaret and the distillery team
  • One private distillery room booking a year
  • Members only surprise drops
  • A welcome polo
  • Everything in Merroir

TERROIR

Free

All things Macaloney's, from the ground up.


  • 10% off every bottle, all year
  • 24 hour early access to Special and Limited releases
  • The monthly Friends Dispatch, by email
  • Invitations to ticketed tastings and distillery events
  • A birthday dram at the distillery
  • Member pricing at the distillery bar